Lawrence: Rupert Murdoch's 'temple of lies' at Fox exposed by Dominion lawsuit
by Lawrence O'Donnell
MSNBC
Feb 27, 2023 #msnbc #rupertmurdoch #foxnews
MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell explains the truths revealed by the latest court filing in Dominion Voting System’s lawsuit against Fox including that Sean Hannity was ‘disgusted’ by Trump and Rupert Murdoch says he ‘could have’ stopped Fox from airing election lies, but didn’t.
Transcript
0:03
>> HERE IS THE MOVIE PITCH, FOR
0:09
CITIZEN MURDOCH, A 21ST
0:11
CENTURY REMAKE OF THE ORSON
0:13
WELLES 1997 CLASSIC CITIZEN
0:15
KAYNA, BUT IT WENT ENORMOUSLY
0:17
WEALTHY NEWSPAPER OWNER.
0:19
ACT, WON A 42 YEAR OLD
0:21
AUSTRALIAN NEWSPAPER OWNER
0:22
STARTS BUYING AMERICAN
0:23
NEWSPAPERS IN 1973, MOVED TO
0:26
NEW YORK IN 1970, FOUR AND
0:28
EXPANDING EXPONENTIALLY BY
0:29
BUYING HIS WAY INTO SHOW
0:31
BUSINESS, WHERE HE SHOWS OUT OF
0:32
HIS HOLLYWOOD STUDIO, THE SAME
0:34
KIND OF MOVIES AND TELEVISION
0:35
PROGRAMS THAT ALL OF THE
0:36
STUDIOS AND NETWORKS ARE DOING.
0:38
IN 1985, HE BECOMES A U.S.
0:42
CITIZEN AND GIVES UP HIS
0:43
AUSTRALIAN CITIZENSHIP.
0:45
ACT TO, TEN YEARS LATER, HE HAS
0:47
MADE SO MANY MONEY THAT HE CAN
0:51
AFFAIR TO LOSE EVERY PENNY THAT
0:53
HE INVESTS IN A LONG SHOT
0:55
GAMBLE ON A TV NETWORK THAT
0:57
PUTS THE WORD NEWS IN ITS TITLE,
1:00
BUT IS MEANT TO DO NOTHING BUT
1:03
FIRST, ELECT REPUBLICANS, AND
1:05
SECOND, DESTROY DEMOCRACY.
1:07
THE NETWORK LOSES MONEY AT
1:09
FIRST, BUT THEN BECOMES A
1:11
BIGGER AND BIGGER PROFIT CENTER
1:12
FOR CITIZEN MURDOCH AND ADDS
1:15
BILLIONS TO HIS WEALTH.
1:18
CITIZEN MURDOCH USES HIS
1:19
NETWORK IN ORDER TO ELECT THE
1:22
STUPIDEST AND MOST CRIMINAL
1:23
PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES
1:25
IN HISTORY.
1:27
ACT THREE, THE CRIMINAL
1:29
PRESIDENT LOSES HIS REELECTION
1:31
CAMPAIGN, AND FEDERAL STATE AND
1:33
LOCAL PROSECUTORS CLOSE IN ON
1:35
HIM.
1:36
AT AGE 90, ONE CITIZEN MURDOCH
1:39
COMPLETES HIS THEIR DIVORCE,
1:42
THIS TIME FROM THE SECOND WOMAN,
1:43
WHO MICK JAGGER DIVORCED 24
1:45
YEARS EARLIER, AND IT IS
1:47
AVAILABLE NOW TO PLAY HERSELF.
1:48
THE DEFENDERS OF DEMOCRACY,
1:50
FINALLY GETTING CITIZEN
1:53
MURDOCH CORNERED, AND FORCE
1:54
HIM TO ADMIT UNDER OATH, WEEKS
1:58
BEFORE HIS 92ND BIRTHDAY, THAT
2:02
WHAT HIS NETWORK IS FORCE
2:05
FEEDING ITS VIEWERS WAS
2:06
BULLSHIT AND DAMAGING.
2:09
WHEN ASKED WHY HE DID NOT STOP,
2:15
SADNESS AND MURDOCH SAID, I
2:17
COULD HAVE.
2:17
BUT I DID NOT.
2:22
THE END.
2:23
ALL OF THE DIALOGUE YOU JUST
2:25
HEARD APPEARS IN THE REDACTED
2:26
PUBLIC WHERE JEAN OF A BRIEF
2:28
FILED BY THE DOMINION VOTING
2:30
SYSTEM CORPORATION, IN HIS
2:32
LAWSUIT AGAINST FOX CORPORATION
2:34
FOR DEFAMATION, BECAUSE RUPERT
2:37
MURDOCH'S FOX NETWORK PUMPED
2:38
OUT A STEADY STREAM OF LIES
2:41
ABOUT DOMINION VOTING MACHINES,
2:42
IN THE OVERALL CAMPAIGN OF LIES
2:44
THAT DONALD TRUMP AND FOX WAGED
2:46
IN THEIR JOINT ATTEMPT TO
2:49
DESTROY AMERICAN DEMOCRACY AND
2:51
KEEP DONALD TRUMP IN THE WHITE
2:52
HOUSE, EVEN THOUGH HE HAD LOST
2:53
HIS ELECTION.
2:56
I COULD HAVE, BUT I DIDN'T.
2:58
THAT IS THE KIND OF ADMISSION
3:04
IT LAWYERS DREAM ABOUT.
3:05
RUPERT MURDOCH, TESTIFYING
3:08
UNDER OATH BY LAWYERS.
3:10
WHEN ASKED WHY HE DID NOT STOP
3:11
THE LIES ABOUT DOMINION, THE
3:14
LAWSUIT IS ABOUT, SAID I COULD
3:18
HAVE, BUT I DID NOT.
3:21
IN ANY OTHER CIVIL CASE, THAT
3:23
WOULD BE AN ADMISSION OF
3:24
LIABILITY THAT THE DEFENDANT
3:26
COULD NOT SURVIVE.
3:27
BUT WITH THAT ADMISSION UNDER
3:30
OATH, THE ONLY THING STANDING
3:32
HERE BETWEEN RUPERT MURDOCH AND
3:33
THE BILLION DOLLAR JUDGMENT
3:35
AGAINST HIM IN COURT, IT'S THE
3:38
FIRST AMENDMENT.
3:38
FOX DEFENSE SO FAR, IT RESTS
3:42
ENTIRELY ON THE FIRST AMENDMENT
3:43
JOURNALISTIC PRINCIPLE THAT
3:45
WHAT DONALD TRUMP WAS SAYING
3:46
ABOUT THE ELECTION WAS
3:46
NEWSWORTHY, AND FOX HAD A FIRST
3:49
AMENDMENT RIGHT TO COVER IT
3:50
UNCRITICALLY.
3:52
DOMINION NEEDS TO PROVE THAT
3:53
RUPERT MURDOCH AND FOX
3:56
EXECUTIVES, IN THE FOX
3:57
ENTERTAINERS, ON TELEVISION,
3:59
THEY KNEW IT WAS ALL A LIE, AND
4:01
THEY PUSHED IT ANYWAYS.
4:04
DOMINION HAS TAKEN THE
4:05
DISCOVERY PROCESS A LONG WAY TO
4:07
PROVING THAT EVERYBODY AT FOX
4:10
KNEW THAT IT WAS A LIE.
4:12
THE MINIONS FILING TODAY, AS
4:15
WE'VE LEARNED, THE FOX LAWYERS
4:17
WERE WORRIED ABOUT SEAN HANNITY
4:19
SAYING THAT IT WILL BE
4:20
IMPOSSIBLE TO EVER KNOW THE
4:21
TRUE, FAIR, ACCURATE ELECTION
4:23
RESULTS.
4:23
THAT IS A FACT.
4:24
ON NOVEMBER 5TH, THE FOX NEWS
4:27
LAWYER EMAILED THAT HE IS
4:29
GETTING AWFULLY CLOSE TO THE
4:31
LINE WITH HIS COMMENTARY, AND
4:32
GUESTS TONIGHT.
4:33
THAT SAME LAWYER WAS ASKED IN A
4:36
DEPOSITION, SHOULD FOX
4:37
BROADCAST ELECTION FRAUD
4:38
ALLEGATIONS?
4:39
THAT IT KNOWS TO BE FALSE, THE
4:41
ANSWER IS NO.
4:42
THE FOX EXECUTIVE ASKED IN A
4:44
DEPOSITION, DO YOU THINK THAT
4:45
FOX HAS AN OBLIGATION NOT TO
4:47
BROADCAST FALSE CLAIMS TO ITS
4:49
AUDIENCE, ANSWER IS YES.
4:51
THE MINIONS FILING REVIEWED HOW
4:53
FOX, WHICH HAS ABSOLUTELY NO
4:56
RELATIONSHIP TO THE NEWS
4:57
BUSINESS, ILLICITLY AND
5:00
SECRETLY HELPED THE TRUMP
5:03
CAMPAIGN BY REVEALING
5:05
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION ABOUT
5:06
THE BIDEN CAMPAIGN'S TV
5:10
ADVERTISEMENT.
5:10
DURING TRUMP'S CAMPAIGN, RUPERT
5:13
PROVIDED TRUMP'S SON-IN-LAW,
5:15
AND SENIOR ADVISER JARED
5:17
KUSHNER WITH FOX CONFIDENTIAL
5:19
INFORMATION ABOUT BIDEN'S ADS,
5:21
ALONG WITH DEBATE STRATEGY
5:23
PROVIDING KUSHNER A PREVIEW OF
5:26
BIDEN'S ADS BEFORE THEY WERE
5:27
PUBLIC.
5:28
THE DEAN FILING SHOWS THAT
5:30
RUPERT MURDOCH NEVER BELIEVED
5:33
THAT THERE WAS THIS SLIGHTEST
5:34
OF IRREGULARITIES IN THE 2020
5:36
PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION.
5:37
IN DECEMBER 2020, THE DOMINION
5:40
FILING SHOWS THAT FORMER
5:42
SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE PAUL RYAN,
5:43
NOW A BOARD MEMBER AT FOX, HE
5:47
TEXTED RUPERT MURDOCH AND HIS
5:49
AIR APPARENT, THAT DONALD TRUMP,
5:52
HAS QUOTE, ACTUALLY CONVINCED
5:55
HIMSELF OF THIS FARCE, IT WILL
5:58
DO MORE BIZARRE THINGS IN ORDER
6:00
TO DELEGITIMIZED THE ELECT
6:01
ELECTION, I SEE THIS AS A KEY
6:03
INFLECTION POINT FOR FOX, WHERE
6:05
THE RIGHT THING AND SMART
6:07
BUSINESS THING TO DO LINEUP
6:09
NICELY.
6:10
HE CALLED FOR FOX TO PUT FORTH
6:11
THE SOLID PUSHBACK, INCLUDING
6:13
EDITORIAL OF TRUMP'S BASELESS
6:15
CALLS TO OVERTURN ELECTORS.
6:17
AFTER RECEIVING THAT TEXT,
6:19
RUPERT MURDOCH WROTE TO HIS SON,
6:21
CALL ME LATER, TRUMP AND PAUL,
6:24
TRUMP ON SATURDAY SOUNDS REALLY
6:25
CRAZY.
6:28
TWO DAYS AFTER THE JANUARY 6TH
6:30
ATTACK ON THE CAPITOL,
6:32
PRESIDENT PATH, THE SHOW
6:34
EXECUTIVE WHO HAD WORKED FOR
6:35
RUPERT MURDOCH IN THE
6:36
ENTERTAINMENT BUSINESS, ON PAGE
6:39
13 OF THE FILING, QUOTE, SENT
6:42
RUPERT AN ARTICLE FROM THE
6:44
WASHINGTON POST, STATING THAT
6:45
THE PROBE TRUMP MEDIA WORLD
6:48
PEDDLED THE LIES THAT FUELED
6:50
THE CAPITAL MOB, FOX NEWS HAD
6:52
NOT FOLLOWED UP WITH THE EMAIL
6:54
STATING, I DO THINK THAT FOX
6:56
NEWS NEEDS A COURSE CORRECTION.
6:57
RUPERT RESPONDED, FOX NEWS,
7:00
VERY BUSY PIVOTING.
7:03
WE WANT TO MAKE TRUMP A
7:04
NON-PERSON.
7:06
MAKE TRUMP A NON-PERSON.
7:10
AND THERE, RIGHT THERE, THE
7:14
MOVIE CITIZEN MURDOCH STORMS
7:18
INTO THE MOVIE FRANKENSTEIN,
7:19
WHERE HE HAS CREATED THE
7:22
MONSTER THAT HE CAN NO LONGER
7:25
CONTROL, AND WANTS TO MAKE A
7:27
NON-PERSON.
7:28
BUT HE CAN'T BE CAUGHT BY HIS
7:30
TRUMP LOVING AUDIENCE IN HIS
7:33
EFFORT TO MAKE TRUMP A
7:35
NON-PERSON.
7:35
AS HE MAKES CLEAR, IN A LATER
7:38
EMAIL TO HIS SON, SAYING QUOTE,
7:42
FOX NEWS, WHICH CALLED THE
7:43
ELECTION CORRECTLY, IS PIVOTING
7:45
AS FAST AS POSSIBLE.
7:47
WE HAVE TO LEAD OUR VIEWERS,
7:48
JUST NOT AS EASY AS IT MIGHT
7:50
SEEM.
7:51
HE SPENT DECADES OBJECTING
7:55
POISON INTO HIS VIEWERS, POISON
7:58
THAT HE REFUSED TO TAKE HIMSELF,
8:01
AND WHEN HE WANTED TO NUDGE HIS
8:03
VIEWERS AWAY FROM TRUMP, HE DID
8:06
NOT KNOW HOW TO DO IT.
8:09
AND HE DID NOT BLAME ANY OF HIS
8:12
PRIMETIME ENTERTAINERS FOR NOT
8:14
EVEN TRYING TO.
8:15
IN AN EMAIL TO PAUL RYAN AFTER
8:18
THAT JANUARY 6TH ATTACK ON THE
8:19
CAPITOL, HE SAID THAT IT WAS,
8:22
QUOTE, THE WAKE UP CALL FOR
8:23
HANNITY, WHO HAS BEEN PRIVATELY
8:26
DISGUSTED BY TRUMP FOR WEEKS,
8:29
BUT WAS SCARED TO LOSE VIEWERS.
8:31
AND SO THERE IS RUPERT MURDOCH,
8:33
HIS BOSS, THE OWNER OF SEAN
8:34
HANNITY'S MICROPHONE, SAYING
8:39
THAT SEAN HANNITY HAS BEEN
8:40
PRIVATELY DISGUSTED BY TRUMP
8:43
FOR WEEKS.
8:44
ANOTHER WAY OF SAYING THAT, AS
8:46
SEAN HANNITY HAS BEEN WILDLY
8:48
LYING TO HIS AUDIENCE ABOUT
8:50
TRUMP FOR WEEKS, PRIVATELY
8:52
DISGUSTED.
8:54
SEAN HANNITY?
8:55
PRIVATELY?
8:56
JOHN HANNITY PLAYS A DISGUSTED
8:59
GUY ON TV, EVERY SINGLE NIGHT
9:01
HAD HIS LIFE.
9:01
HE PLAYS A GUY DISGUSTED BY
9:03
SOMETHING, OR EVERYTHING.
9:05
ON THE LEFT SIDE OF AMERICAN
9:08
POLITICS, DISCUSSED IN SEAN
9:10
HANNITY'S BRAND.
9:12
THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT SEAN
9:15
HANNITY HAD THE BASIC HUMAN
9:17
DECENCY TO BE DISGUSTED BY
9:18
DONALD TRUMP.
9:19
THE BAD NEWS IS THAT RUPERT
9:22
MURDOCH BUILT THE PROPAGANDA
9:24
MACHINE IN WHICH HE AND SEAN
9:27
HANNITY COULD GET VERY RICH.
9:31
AS LONG AS THEY ONLY PRIVATELY
9:33
WERE DISGUSTED BY DONALD TRUMP.
9:36
IT'S THE SAME THING WITH TUCKER
9:38
CARLSON, WHO WAS SHOWN IN A
9:39
PREVIOUS DOMINION FILING TO BEG
9:44
THE THEN MORE POWERFUL, HIGHER
9:45
RATED SEAN HANNITY, TO GET A
9:48
FOX REPORTER FIRED FOR
9:50
ACCURATELY FACT CHECKING DONALD
9:52
TRUMP IN A TWEET.
9:53
FIRING, FIRING WAS THE VERY
9:58
FIRST IMPULSE FOR THE BORNE
10:00
RICH TUCKER CARLSON, WHO NOW
10:02
SEES TENS OF MILLIONS OF
10:04
DOLLARS LYING TO FOX VIEWERS
10:06
EVERY SINGLE NIGHT.
10:07
ESPECIALLY ABOUT HIS PERSONAL
10:10
DISCUSSED FOR DONALD TRUMP.
10:12
THE TUCKER CARLSON, WHO HAS
10:15
NEVER HAD A DAY OF FINANCIAL
10:16
STRUGGLE IN HIS LIFE, THAT SAME
10:20
TUCKER CARLSON, HE HAD A FIRST
10:22
IMPULSE OF FIRING A REPORTER
10:24
WHO, IN HER LIFETIME, WILL NOT
10:26
EARN THE INCOME THAT TUCKER
10:28
CARLSON GETS IN A YEAR OF LYING
10:31
FOR RUPERT MURDOCH'S
10:34
MONSTROSITY THAT IS NOW BEING
10:36
EXPOSED.
10:38
BY THE DOMINION LAWSUIT.
10:41
IN HIS DEPOSITION, RUPERT
10:43
MURDOCH WAS ASKED, WHAT SHOULD
10:45
THE CONSEQUENCES BE WHEN FOX
10:46
NEWS EXECUTIVES KNOWINGLY ALLOW
10:48
LIES TO BE BROADCAST?
10:50
THE ANSWER, THEY SHOULD BE
10:51
REPRIMANDED.
10:52
THEY SHOULD BE REPRIMANDED,
10:53
MAYBE GOTTEN RID OF.
10:55
RUPERT MURDOCH IS THE TOP
10:59
EXECUTIVE IN THAT COMPANY.
11:00
HE KNOWINGLY ALLOWED LIES TO BE
11:04
BROADCAST BY THE RUPERT RULE.
11:07
HE SHOULD BE REPRIMANDED.
11:09
AND MAYBE GOTTEN RID OF.
11:13
EVERYBODY KNOWS THAT THAT WILL
11:15
NEVER HAPPEN, BECAUSE AS
11:16
EVERYBODY THAT WORKS IN, THAT
11:20
TEMPLE OF LIES KNOWS, RUPERT'S
11:23
RULES DO NOT APPLY TO CITIZEN MURDOCH.